Employment tribunal fees were ‘a barrier to victims seeking justice when they have suffered human rights abuses’, according to an influential group of MPs. The House of Commons’ joint committee on human rights have added their collective voice to the justice and equalities committees in calling on the Government to cut the charges introduced in 2013.
A new report from the committee, Human Rights and Business 2017 quotes the Equality and Human Rights Commission which expressed its concern ‘about the substantial drop in workplace discrimination cases’ following the introduction of fees. ‘This is particularly marked for cases involving discrimination on the basis of sex, disability, race and sexual orientation, and cases on equal pay and unfair dismissal,’ the group said. ‘Given that over four-fifths of claimants for sex discrimination and equal pay cases are women, the introduction of tribunal fees has had a disproportionate impact on this group.’
The Equality Commission flagged up Ministry of Justice (MoJ) statistics which revealed a 43% drop in race discrimination claims and a 64% in religion or belief discrimination claims.
The justice minister Sir Oliver Heald assured MPs that the policy ‘worked in the way that we intended it to, which was, first, that we would recover some money to help with the costs of running the tribunals and we recovered about the amount that we expected’. ‘Secondly, we wanted to improve the take-up of conciliation,’ he added.
The MoJ argued that the introduction of fees alongside the introduction of ACAS’s early conciliation service had ‘led to a dramatic shift in the way that employment related disputes are dealt with’ and this was ‘helping many more people to resolve their workplace disputes while avoiding the stress and cost of the tribunal’.
The human rights committee report quoted the conclusion of fellow MPs on the justice committee in their inquiry into court and tribunal fees saying the MoJ’s logic was ‘even on the most favourable construction, superficial’. The report also quoted the finding of the women and equalities committee which had called for ‘a substantial reduction in tribunal fees for discrimination cases’.
‘We join the Commons Justice and Women and Equalities Committees in calling on the Government to reduce employment tribunal fees. These, it is clear to us, are a barrier to victims seeking justice when they have suffered human rights abuses, including discrimination, at the hands of their employers and offer impunity for employers abusing human rights.’
House of Commons’ joint committee on human rights
- Government is ‘failing’ victims of trafficking by denying legal aid - 13th October 2017
- JusticeWatch: Is it time to axe the LAA? - 13th October 2017
- A cross-party group MPs call for LASPO review as ’a matter of urgency’ - 13th October 2017
- JusticeWatch: LASPO review ‘a bit like waiting for Godot’ - 6th October 2017
- LAA more interested in ‘refusing aid’ than access to justice, say LAPG - 6th October 2017
- JusticeWatch: Something’s got to give - 29th September 2017
- Bach Commission: ‘Justice is far too precious to be a party political football’ - 27th September 2017
- JusticeWatch: ‘A justice system in crisis’ - 22nd September 2017
- Bach Commission calls for ‘legally enforceable’ right to justice and for eligibility to legal aid to cover half of all households - 22nd September 2017
- ‘I don’t think we’ve listened enough,’ says head of courts - 20th September 2017